top of page

It took me five years to discover what Thanksgiving was really about.

I had been in America for just eight weeks when I celebrated my first Thanksgiving.

Eight weeks. Barely enough time to find my feet, let alone understand the customs of an entirely new country.

I was living in Fort Lauderdale, Florida, having recently left a job as an executive chef. I was excited to be in America. Everything was new, the sunshine, the people, the possibilities. There was a wonderful sense of adventure about it all, although beneath the excitement was a little nervousness about how my future might unfold. I had left behind the familiar comforts of England, and I hadn't the faintest idea where life might take me.

Three days before Thanksgiving, someone mentioned the holiday.

Apparently, the whole country was preparing an enormous dinner. There would be turkey, stuffing, potatoes, vegetables and something called pumpkin pie.

I had never celebrated Thanksgiving before. I wasn't entirely sure what we were giving thanks for, but as I was the only professional cook among a bunch of English lads, I was promptly nominated to prepare the meal.

And so, on Thanksgiving morning, I found myself in a tiny condo with ingredients covering every inch of the dining table.

The place was so small that opening the oven door put you technically in the living room. There was barely room to turn around, and certainly nowhere sensible to put the shop-bought pie, so I placed it carefully on a dining chair for safekeeping.

That, as it turned out, was a mistake.

I spent the day cooking, the little condo slowly filling with the smell of sage, butter and roasting turkey.

The others went to the pub.

They left promising they'd just have the one.

In the entire history of England, I don't believe that sentence has ever once been true.

By the time they returned, they had consumed considerably more alcohol than their livers could reasonably process.

The door banged open and in they came, smelling of lager and sunshine, descending upon dinner like a crew of Vikings who had spent six months rowing across the North Atlantic without seeing a decent meal.

There was shouting, laughter, a considerable amount of drunken nonsense and precious little in the way of thank yous.

They ate everything in sight.

When it came time for dessert, I went looking for the pie.

Darren had been sitting on it for the entire meal.

He was so drunk he hadn't noticed. When he finally stood up, the pie came with him for a good second before surrendering to gravity.

I stood there looking at the remains.

So much for dessert.

Half the lads fell asleep. The others wandered off to the pool. And I was left with a kitchen full of dirty dishes and a pumpkin pie that looked as though it had been involved in a minor road accident.

I remember standing at the sink, washing plates, wondering what on earth Americans found so charming about Thanksgiving.

It reminded me of Christmas Day growing up in England, when people would return from the pub expecting a roast dinner to appear.

Except there were no presents, no Christmas crackers and, rather disappointingly, I was the poor sod doing all the washing up.

I couldn't see the attraction.

The next few Thanksgivings weren't particularly memorable either.

Somewhere along the way, I decided to make my first pumpkin pie.

I found a recipe in a magazine and bought a tin of pumpkin purée.

I remember wrestling with a dreadful old tin opener, its blade rusty and blunt, until eventually the lid gave way.

I dipped in a teaspoon.

What came out was a spoonful of watery orange mush.

I tasted it.

Good Lord.

It was bland and dull, with none of the sweetness or depth I had expected. I looked into the tin, wondering why anyone would want to turn this into a dessert.

Perhaps, I thought, the problem wasn't the pie. Perhaps it was the way I was making it.

So I bought a butternut squash.

I sliced it in half and roasted it until the flesh was tender and sweet, the edges turning a deep golden brown. The kitchen filled with a warm, nutty smell, and when I scraped the soft flesh from its skin, I knew I had found something worth working with.

It was rich, smooth and naturally sweet.

With a little orange zest, warm spices and a splash of Grand Marnier, the filling became something altogether different.

For the first time, I could see why someone might look forward to pumpkin pie.

I still hadn't quite worked out Thanksgiving, but at least dessert was improving.

Then, in my fifth year in America, Jan and Jerry invited us to spend Thanksgiving with their family in Altamonte Springs.

They asked me to bring the pies.

This time, I made sure nobody sat on them.

I was thrilled to be asked. Cooking has always been one of my favourite ways of showing someone I care. I love the thought of arriving at someone's door carrying something I've made with my own hands.

We drove the forty-five miles from Celebration on a warm Florida afternoon, the pies travelling with rather more care than most passengers.

When we arrived, we were greeted with big hugs and cheerful wishes of Happy Thanksgiving.

The house was full.

Family had travelled from across the country to be together, and along the sideboard stood framed photographs of the very people now crowding the kitchen.

Within minutes, we had been introduced to everyone.

There was the lovely noise of a family gathering, conversations overlapping, people moving between the kitchen and dining room, someone laughing in another part of the house.

The table ran the length of the room, beautifully dressed for autumn.

Every place had a name card.

Tucked into each golden charger was a scratch card and a lottery ticket.

I didn't win a penny, although by the end of the afternoon I felt as though I had.

What struck me was how naturally we had been included. There was no sense of being outsiders, no awkwardness about joining a family celebration that wasn't originally ours.

There were simply two more places at the table.

We ate, talked and laughed.

And then, at the end of the meal, everyone took a moment to say what they were thankful for.

I had never experienced anything quite like it.

Growing up in Liverpool, we weren't particularly accustomed to sitting around the dinner table telling one another how much we appreciated each other.

We loved one another, of course, but we were more likely to express it by offering someone another roast potato or asking whether they fancied a cup of tea.

Here, people were speaking openly about the things that mattered to them.

Their families. Their friendships. The simple pleasure of being together.

I listened.

Then came the pies.

The pastry was crisp and buttery, the filling soft and fragrant with orange zest and warm spices. The Grand Marnier lingered gently in the background, just enough to make you wonder what it was.

Jerry tasted his.

He looked up and said something I have never forgotten.

"All my life I've eaten pumpkin pie because of tradition. This year, I would love this recipe to become part of our tradition."

I smiled.

I didn't have the heart to tell him there wasn't a scrap of pumpkin in it.

Some secrets are best kept until after the second slice.

Over the years, I've been fortunate enough to receive many compliments about my cooking. But this one was different.

Jerry wasn't simply telling me that he liked a pie.

He was offering it a place in something his family treasured.

The thought that a recipe of mine might appear on their Thanksgiving table year after year, perhaps eventually made by children or grandchildren, meant more to me than I could easily explain.

I felt humbled.

I had arrived with a few pies and left with a memory that would stay with me for the rest of my life.

These days, Thanksgiving is one of my favourite occasions of the year.

We live on Martha's Vineyard now, where November brings a different sort of beauty. The island grows quieter, the summer visitors have gone, and the air carries that unmistakable chill that makes a warm kitchen feel particularly inviting.

I still spend much of Thanksgiving cooking.

The television is usually on in the living room, and I wander in and out to catch a little of the parade. I love the dog show too, watching those beautifully groomed creatures parade about while my own kitchen is in its usual state of cheerful disorder.

And then there is Lady Ashton's table.

She takes such pleasure in making it beautiful, and I love seeing what she has created. The arrangement of the plates, the glasses catching the light, the little touches that make an ordinary room feel ready for an occasion.

It looks wonderful before anyone arrives.

But I think it looks even better once everyone has sat down, the conversation has begun and the food is being passed around.

One of my greatest pleasures is cooking for neighbours who don't have family nearby.

I know what it feels like to be far from home, particularly during a holiday when everyone seems to be gathering with the people they love.

And there is something deeply satisfying about knowing that someone has a place to come, a chair waiting for them and a good meal to enjoy.

Not long ago, an eighty-three-year-old neighbour tasted my pumpkin pie for the first time.

She had never particularly cared for pumpkin pie before.

But this one, made with roasted squash, orange zest and a little Grand Marnier, changed her mind.

I thought of Jerry.

All those years ago, he had sat at his Thanksgiving table and told me he wanted my pie to become part of his family's tradition.

Now here I was, years later, offering the same pie to someone else.

I still love the turkey, of course. A beautifully roasted bird is a glorious thing.

But I have grown particularly fond of the moment when dessert arrives.

There is a quiet joy in watching someone take a forkful of a humble pie and discover a little unexpected pleasure.

I think of Jan and Jerry often at this time of year.

I wonder if they ever realised how much that invitation meant to a young Englishman who was still finding his way in America.

Probably not.

They were simply being themselves, opening their home, gathering their family and making room for two more people at the table.

But kindness has a funny way of travelling.

Someone makes room for you at their table, and years later, you find yourself making room for someone else.

I arrived in America knowing how to cook a Thanksgiving dinner.

It took me five years to discover the recipe for Thanksgiving itself.

A Little Piece of My Thanksgiving Table

The pie that changed everything is still one of my favourite things to make. Slowly roasted butternut squash, fragrant orange zest, warm spices and a splash of Grand Marnier, all tucked into buttery pastry.

It is the pie I carried to Jan and Jerry's table, and the one I still love sharing with friends and neighbours today.

If you'd like to make it for someone you love this Thanksgiving, here is the recipe.

If you've never made pumpkin pie before, or you'd like to know why roasting the squash makes all the difference, my free Pumpkin Pie Masterclass walks you through every step.

Jan and Jerry made room for two more at their table. Every November since, I have tried to do the same.

A question for you: Whose kindness are you still passing on, perhaps without them ever knowing?

yellowpattern.png

The Recipe for Thanksgiving

The Recipe for Thanksgiving
bottom of page